I need a little help. We made this turkey meatball recipe last week, and it was great. The flavor was wonderful, and we ate it with spaghetti and our homemade spaghetti sauce. The only problem was that the meatballs fell apart. Essentially, we ate spaghetti with a very meaty sauce. It was delicious but not at all what we were going for.
So I'm hoping you experienced meatballers will take a look at the recipe and tell me what we should do differently to make them stay solid, like meatballs.
Recipe is based on one we found in the Prevention Slow Cooker Recipe Book
Photo by jshj
Shelley says
I'd probably brown them in a little olive oil first, before adding them to the crock pot. This way, they will have a little 'crust' on them, making them less likely to fall apart.
Renee says
Sounds good. Try either baking them first or at least browning them before you put them in the crockpot, that should help.
[email protected] says
Hi Tara, I really have no idea why your meatballs fell apart. I don't make mine in the crockpot. Looking over your ingredients, I can't see any reason they would. You have a binder, egg and breadcrumbs and the only thing I could see is that maybe ground turkey does not have enough fat and moisture in it to survive the crock pot. Just a guess.
I want to thank you for the stellar job you did in Baltimore!!!! I introduced myself to you- I'm the "mature" lady from Lancaster. I though your presentation was more than fabulous! So very,very well organized and informative. You really know your subject. Hands down you made this Blogging Bootcamp worthwile just by yourself. A big, big thank you . I learned so much from you!
Yvonne
upstatemomof3 says
I wish I had some advice for you but I have found the same problem with turkey meat. It sort of falls apart on me. 🙂
Kristen says
I agree with Shelley. When I make meatballs, I make up a huge batch, bake them on a wire rack set into a cookie sheet, then freeze them. They don't fall apart when I put them into the crockpot, BUT! I haven't made them with turkey.
Tiffanee says
I always shape my meatballs and bake them on a cookie sheet for about 15-20 minutes. Depending on the size. Then I flash freeze them. Then I can just add them to the crockpot or whatever dish I want. I hope this helps.
Charlene says
Try pre-cooking your meatballs a bit--put them on a baking sheet (with sides, to catch the grease/juice) and bake for a few minutes, then add to your sauce. I don't know that even then I'd let them cook all day in the sauce. Maybe try baking the meatballs, cook just the sauce all day, then add the meatballs for the last hour or two.
Robyn's Online World says
I would say to bake your meatballs and cook them all the way first. You could make a big batch one day. Then freeze them. Whenever you want this dish, just take the frozen meatballs and add them to the crockpot with your other ingredients/sauce.
Debra Legg says
I do what Robin does: Bake them in advance then put in the Crock Pot just long enough to give them a saucy flavor - maybe an hour. Another thing that I've found with meatballs - I worked my way through college in an Italian restaurant - is that you have to really roll them hard to get everything to bind. Like, a half minute or so per ball. The finished ones should be very, very smooth.
Staci says
I'm not really any help on why they fell apart, but they sound yummy! We usually make meatballs up in a big batch, bake, and freeze them. Then I can toss them in the crock pot that way, and they usually hold their form.
Good luck!
Ann Kroeker says
Mmmm...I love meatballs but never have the nerve to make them. So I have nothing to offer you in terms of trouble-shooting, but I will say that your picture looks scrumptious!
Brenda says
I need to try this, we have been cooking a lot more with ground turkey instead of beef.
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
That's a great idea! We considered baking them the next time, too.
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
That's what we were thinking, too.
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
The sauce is already cooked, so I'm thinking that maybe we should just be tossing the meatballs and sauce into a regular pan on the stove to heat through and then serve?
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
Isn't that odd? A previous commenter said maybe it's because the turkey doesn't have enough fat to hold the meatballs together. Maybe that's it?
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
They were delicious even though they fell apart.
upstatemomof3 says
Huh!! Maybe. It is really odd.
Kelly Hupcey says
Love your blog! Those meatballs look sooo good, love me some spaghetti and meatballs! Following you now!
http://thepursuitofmommyness.com/
bj says
ummm..these sound so good...
Jane says
I love anything in a slow cooker. This looks and sounds delicious. I can only think that the meatbals might be overcooking...
xoxo
Jane
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
They really were. 🙂
FeelsLikeHomeBlog says
I think so, too. I was home sick the day we made them, and I turned the crockpot off around noon. They might have cooked for 5 hours, but I do think they were over done.
On the other hand, I have friends who put their meatballs in sauce in the crockpot at parties, and they don't fall apart. 🙁
Mrs. Jen B says
I, too, have cooked meatballs in the crock pot for parties and such. I do sometimes have problems with breakage - as I mentioned in my post today regarding my meatballs which I cooked for hours and hours - but I agree with others who suggest pre-cooking. I generally bake them and then toss them in - you still flavor the sauce with the meat, and vice versa. Also, maybe more breadcrumbs to hold them together, or ripped-up dry bread?
Mrs. Jen B says
I, too, have cooked meatballs in the crock pot for parties and such. I do sometimes have problems with breakage - as I mentioned in my post today regarding my meatballs which I cooked for hours and hours - but I agree with others who suggest pre-cooking. I generally bake them and then toss them in - you still flavor the sauce with the meat, and vice versa. Also, maybe more breadcrumbs to hold them together, or ripped-up dry bread?
Daisyh80 says
A great way to keep your crockpot meatballs from falling apart! Shape your meatballs then roll them in red wine vinegar, then on a high heat pan with olive oil already heated, roll them so that they become dark and almost crispy on the outside (the red wine vinegar gives them a caramel like glaze) then allow to cool for 5-10 min. THEN add them to your crockpot for final cooking.